Log In | Create Account
Reggie Yinger
Slow AL-Only Mock Draft Results
Wednesday December 23rd, 2009

About a week ago, I started into my first mock draft of the season thanks to Jason Collette of Dock Of The Rays. This draft was a slow AL-Only (8 hours between picks) mock draft that consisted of 12 teams and 23 rounds hosted by Couch Managers. Below are the requirements for each position. The utility player could be anything (with the exception of a pitcher) and a DH was not required. The pitcher slots could also be either a starting pitcher or a relief pitcher.

C1B2B3BSSCIMIUOFP
2111111159

I'm not going to review each pick because that would just be boring and I'll doubt you read about every single pick in every round, but I will cover the highlights of the first five rounds. If you are interested, the table below allows you to view each pick by the round. With the draft taking place during the winter hot stove, some players were switching leagues and being taken by owners when they should of been excluded (OF Mike Cameron was drafted in the 19th round and would have been drafted way earlier). With that said, you may see some very strange picks and those should be scratched from your memory.


Scroll to round: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23
Round 1
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
1.1Joe Mauer C Dwade
1.2Alex Rodriguez 3B jasoncollette
1.3Miguel Cabrera 1B RayFlowers
1.4Mark Teixeira 1B jessespector
1.5Carl Crawford OF sacksjacked
1.6Evan Longoria 3B pjs24
1.7Ian Kinsler 2B jintman
1.8Zack Greinke SP ajwalsh08
1.9Jason Bay OF theroundtable
1.10Derek Jeter SS donnysamson
1.11Aaron Hill 2B joelhenard
1.12Grady Sizemore OF chata
Round 2
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
2.13Victor Martinez C chata
2.14Kevin Youkilis 1B joelhenard
2.15Cliff Lee SP donnysamson
2.16Justin Morneau 1B theroundtable
2.17Jacoby Ellsbury OF ajwalsh08
2.18Felix Hernandez SP jintman
2.19Robinson Cano 2B pjs24
2.20Brian Roberts 2B sacksjacked
2.21Curtis Granderson OF jessespector
2.22Ichiro Suzuki OF RayFlowers
2.23Ben Zobrist 2B jasoncollette
2.24Dustin Pedroia 2B Dwade
Round 3
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
3.25Kendry Morales 1B Dwade
3.26C.C. Sabathia SP jasoncollette
3.27Nick Markakis OF RayFlowers
3.28Justin Verlander SP jessespector
3.29Michael Young 3B sacksjacked
3.30Adam Lind OF pjs24
3.31Bobby Abreu OF jintman
3.32Chone Figgins 3B ajwalsh08
3.33Josh Hamilton OF theroundtable
3.34Josh Beckett SP donnysamson
3.35Nelson Cruz OF joelhenard
3.36Michael Cuddyer OF chata
Round 4
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
4.37Matt Wieters C chata
4.38Shin-Soo Choo OF joelhenard
4.39Jon Lester SP donnysamson
4.40Jose Lopez 2B theroundtable
4.41Torii Hunter OF ajwalsh08
4.42Mariano Rivera RP jintman
4.43Billy Butler 1B pjs24
4.44Jonathan Papelbon RP sacksjacked
4.45Joe Nathan RP jessespector
4.46Alexei Ramirez SS RayFlowers
4.47Johnny Damon OF jasoncollette
4.48Jason Bartlett SS Dwade
Round 5
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
5.49Jered Weaver SP Dwade
5.50Carlos Pena 1B jasoncollette
5.51Jhonny Peralta 3B RayFlowers
5.52Gordon Beckham 3B jessespector
5.53Elvis Andrus SS sacksjacked
5.54Joakim Soria RP pjs24
5.55Carlos Quentin OF jintman
5.56Adam Jones OF ajwalsh08
5.57Jorge Posada C theroundtable
5.58B.J. Upton OF donnysamson
5.59Jake Peavy SP joelhenard
5.60Asdrubal Cabrera SS chata
Round 6
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
6.61Erick Aybar SS chata
6.62Marco Scutaro SS joelhenard
6.63Alexis Rios OF donnysamson
6.64John Lackey SP theroundtable
6.65Mike Napoli C ajwalsh08
6.66Kurt Suzuki C jintman
6.67Jason Kubel DH pjs24
6.68Howie Kendrick 2B sacksjacked
6.69A.J. Pierzynski C jessespector
6.70A.J. Burnett SP RayFlowers
6.71Gavin Floyd SP jasoncollette
6.72David Aardsma RP Dwade
Round 7
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
7.73Scott Baker SP Dwade
7.74Franklin Gutierrez OF jasoncollette
7.75Matt Garza SP RayFlowers
7.76Denard Span OF jessespector
7.77Jermaine Dye OF sacksjacked
7.78Rajai Davis OF pjs24
7.79John Danks SP jintman
7.80Albert Callaspo 2B ajwalsh08
7.81Adrian Beltre 3B theroundtable
7.82Juan L Rivera OF donnysamson
7.83Brett Anderson SP joelhenard
7.84Paul Konerko 1B chata
Round 8
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
8.85J.D. Drew OF chata
8.86Andrew Bailey RP joelhenard
8.87Brian Fuentes RP donnysamson
8.88Joe Saunders SP theroundtable
8.89James Shields SP ajwalsh08
8.90Brandon Inge 3B jintman
8.91Kevin Slowey SP pjs24
8.92Chris Davis 1B sacksjacked
8.93David Price SP jessespector
8.94Vladimir Guerrero DH RayFlowers
8.95Russell Branyan 1B jasoncollette
8.96Nick Swisher OF Dwade
Round 9
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
9.97Rick Porcello SP Dwade
9.98Gio Gonzalez SP jasoncollette
9.99Frank Francisco RP RayFlowers
9.100Rafael Soriano RP jessespector
9.101Max Scherzer SP sacksjacked
9.102Jeff Niemann SP pjs24
9.103Clay Buchholz SP jintman
9.104Orlando Cabrera SS ajwalsh08
9.105Nolan Reimold OF theroundtable
9.106David Ortiz DH donnysamson
9.107Scott Feldman SP joelhenard
9.108Bobby Jenks RP chata
Round 10
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
10.109Rich Harden SP chata
10.110Scott Sizemore 2B joelhenard
10.111Scott Kazmir SP donnysamson
10.112Kerry Wood RP theroundtable
10.113Andy Pettitte SP ajwalsh08
10.114Hideki Matsui DH jintman
10.115Alex Gordon 3B pjs24
10.116Magglio Ordonez OF sacksjacked
10.117J.J. Hardy SS jessespector
10.118Vernon Wells OF RayFlowers
10.119Travis Snider OF jasoncollette
10.120Marlon Byrd OF Dwade
Round 11
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
11.121Mark Teahen 3B Dwade
11.122Brandon Wood 3B jasoncollette
11.123Chris Getz 2B RayFlowers
11.124Neftali Feliz RP jessespector
11.125Ricky Romero SP sacksjacked
11.126Francisco Liriano SP pjs24
11.127Mark Buehrle SP jintman
11.128David DeJesus OF ajwalsh08
11.129Luke Scott DH theroundtable
11.130Mark Ellis 2B donnysamson
11.131Juan Pierre OF joelhenard
11.132Jake Fox 3B chata
Round 12
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
12.133Julio Borbon DH chata
12.134Carlos Santana C joelhenard
12.135Jarrod Saltalamacchia C donnysamson
12.136Daisuke Matsuzaka SP theroundtable
12.137Hank Blalock 1B ajwalsh08
12.138Jeremy Hermida OF jintman
12.139Luis Valbuena 2B pjs24
12.140Ervin Santana SP sacksjacked
12.141Maicer Izturis 2B jessespector
12.142Wade Davis SP RayFlowers
12.143Mike Aviles SS jasoncollette
12.144Mike Lowell 3B Dwade
Round 13
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
13.145Brian Matusz SP Dwade
13.146Joba Chamberlain SP jasoncollette
13.147Delmon Young OF RayFlowers
13.148Ryan Rowland-Smith SP jessespector
13.149Scott Hairston OF sacksjacked
13.150Matt LaPorta OF pjs24
13.151Adam Kennedy 3B jintman
13.152David Murphy OF ajwalsh08
13.153Cesar Izturis SS theroundtable
13.154Aubrey Huff 1B donnysamson
13.155Lyle Overbay 1B joelhenard
13.156Erik Bedard SP chata
Round 14
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
14.157Fernando Rodney RP chata
14.158Travis Hafner DH joelhenard
14.159Scott Downs RP donnysamson
14.160Kevin Millwood SP theroundtable
14.161Ty Wigginton 1B ajwalsh08
14.162Cliff Pennington SS jintman
14.163Mike Gonzalez RP pjs24
14.164Jack Cust DH sacksjacked
14.165Pat Burrell DH jessespector
14.166Brett Wallace 3B RayFlowers
14.167Ryan Sweeney OF jasoncollette
14.168Melky Cabrera OF Dwade
Round 15
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
15.169Alexi Casilla 2B Dwade
15.170Phil Hughes RP jasoncollette
15.171Matt Thornton RP RayFlowers
15.172Edwin Encarnacion 3B jessespector
15.173Gil Meche SP sacksjacked
15.174Derek Holland SP pjs24
15.175Kelly Shoppach C jintman
15.176Carl Pavano SP ajwalsh08
15.177Rod Barajas C theroundtable
15.178Josh Fields 3B donnysamson
15.179Gerald Laird C joelhenard
15.180Jake Westbrook SP chata
Round 16
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
16.181Ryan Raburn OF chata
16.182Joel Zumaya RP joelhenard
16.183Joe Crede 3B donnysamson
16.184Brett Gardner OF theroundtable
16.185Dallas Braden SP ajwalsh08
16.186Daric Barton 1B jintman
16.187Shaun Marcum SP pjs24
16.188Alex Avila C sacksjacked
16.189Miguel Olivo C jessespector
16.190Carlos Guillen OF RayFlowers
16.191Michael Wuertz RP jasoncollette
16.192Lou Marson C Dwade
Round 17
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
17.193Luke Hochevar SP Dwade
17.194Matt Joyce OF jasoncollette
17.195Jason Frasor RP RayFlowers
17.196Jose Guillen OF jessespector
17.197Mike Carp 1B sacksjacked
17.198Brad Bergesen SP pjs24
17.199Nick Johnson 1B jintman
17.200Yuniesky Betancourt SS ajwalsh08
17.201Alex Gonzalez SS theroundtable
17.202Brandon Morrow RP donnysamson
17.203Coco Crisp OF joelhenard
17.204Willy Aybar 1B chata
Round 18
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
18.205Chris Perez RP chata
18.206Trevor Cahill SP joelhenard
18.207Desmond Jennings OF donnysamson
18.208Jarrod Washburn SP theroundtable
18.209Tommy Hunter SP ajwalsh08
18.210Michael Brantley OF jintman
18.211Daniel Bard RP pjs24
18.212Robinson Tejeda RP sacksjacked
18.213Felix Pie OF jessespector
18.214John Buck C RayFlowers
18.215Darren O'Day RP jasoncollette
18.216Austin Jackson OF Dwade
Round 19
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
19.217Justin Duchscherer SP Dwade
19.218Dioner Navarro C jasoncollette
19.219Willie Bloomquist OF RayFlowers
19.220Jeremy Guthrie SP jessespector
19.221Chris Tillman SP sacksjacked
19.222Jayson Nix 2B pjs24
19.223Brandon League RP jintman
19.224Mike Cameron OF ajwalsh08
19.225Nick Blackburn SP theroundtable
19.226Jose Bautista OF donnysamson
19.227Justin Masterson RP joelhenard
19.228Marc Rzepczynski SP chata
Round 20
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
20.229C.J. Wilson RP chata
20.230J.P. Howell RP joelhenard
20.231Jerry Hairston Jr. 3B donnysamson
20.232Andy Marte 1B theroundtable
20.233Brandon McCarthy SP ajwalsh08
20.234Endy Chavez OF jintman
20.235Wilkin Ramirez DH pjs24
20.236Jeremy Bonderman RP sacksjacked
20.237Ian Snell SP jessespector
20.238Ryan Perry RP RayFlowers
20.239David Robertson RP jasoncollette
20.240Darren Oliver RP Dwade
Round 21
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
21.241Andruw Jones DH Dwade
21.242Brayan Pena C jasoncollette
21.243Jason Kendall C RayFlowers
21.244Jack Wilson SS jessespector
21.245Rob Johnson C sacksjacked
21.246Jason Varitek C pjs24
21.247Koji Uehara SP jintman
21.248Brett Cecil SP ajwalsh08
21.249Brian Duensing SP theroundtable
21.250Taylor Teagarden C donnysamson
21.251David Hernandez SP joelhenard
21.252Kevin Jepsen RP chata
Round 22
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
22.253Eric Chavez 3B chata
22.254Michael Aubrey 1B joelhenard
22.255Brad Ziegler RP donnysamson
22.256Aaron Laffey SP theroundtable
22.257David Huff SP ajwalsh08
22.258Chien-Ming Wang SP jintman
22.259Randy Ruiz DH pjs24
22.260John McDonald SS sacksjacked
22.261Fausto Carmona SP jessespector
22.262Vin Mazzaro SP RayFlowers
22.263Ramon Santiago SS jasoncollette
22.264Scott Podsednik OF Dwade
Round 23
RoundPlayerPositionOwners
23.265Dan Wheeler RP Dwade
23.266Grant Balfour RP jasoncollette
23.267Alfredo Aceves RP RayFlowers
23.268Xavier Nady OF jessespector
23.269Phil Coke RP sacksjacked
23.270Landon Powell C pjs24
23.271Jon Rauch RP jintman
23.272Ramon Castro C ajwalsh08
23.273Josh Anderson OF theroundtable
23.274Ramon Ramirez RP donnysamson
23.275Milton Bradley OF joelhenard

The first four picks are pretty self explanatory and reasonable, no real questions here. I had the 5th pick overall (team name sacksjacked) and I decided to go with OF Carl Crawford. A mistake by me for taking Crawford over 3B Evan Longoria? Several owners may say so, but I've always been a speed guy and because it's a stat category where many players lack, it becomes very valuable.

The 9th pick overall was OF Jason Bay by owner Collin Hager (theroundtable) of Elmhurst Pub Roundtable. People of the fantasy baseball world keep saying that Bay is overrated, but his numbers say otherwise. If anything, Bay may have been taken a few picks too early, but the pick isn't totally absurd. Bay could end up with any team and if rumors are true about him signing with an AL West team, he's a solid number three hitter who can produce a ton of points.

The 10th pick was SS Derek Jeter who went earlier than I expected, but owner Donny Samson now has a stud shortstop and can move on with filling other positions. The 11th pick overall was from owner Joel Henard of the Fantasy Insiders and his selection was 2B Aaron Hill. The Hill pick is risky this early, especially with plenty of power hitters still on the board.

Drafted in the final slot of the first round was OF Grady Sizemore, who I thought was a steal. Sizmore had the injuries last year and let a lot of owners down, but is expected to be fully healthy next season. With Grady producing his "normal" stud numbers, owner chata makes this pick a good one.

Halfway through the second round, the draft had a hiccup and owner Alex Walsh (ajwalsh08) was assigned OF Jacoby Ellsbury by accident. I really wanted Ellsbury (really a speed freak for my teams) and offered to draft a player Walsh wanted so we could make a trade. The request was for 2B Brian Roberts, so I made the pick and then swapped it for Jacoby.

I made the Ellsbury/Roberts deal after my target for the second round was taken. I really had my eyes on RHP Felix Hernandez, but he was taken quickly by owner Scott Gilroy (jintman). I decided not to chase another pitcher because I've never been a fan of drafting pitchers high as I feel I just end up chasing after strikeouts and wins, but I really wanted to take a chance on King Felix..it just didn't work out.

With the 9th pick in the second round, owner Jesse Spector of the Touching Base Blog on NYDailyNews.com selected OF Curtis Granderson. Granderson will be a hot item come draft time next season, especially with the move to Yankee Stadium.

Ray Flowers of Baseball Guys selected OF Ichiro Suzuki with the very next pick after Granderson. Can't go wrong with Ichiro, especially on a much improved Mariners team. If anything, Ichiro may have been taken too late. Oh well.

Slugger OF/2B Ben Zobrist was taken by Jason Collette with the 11th pick in the second round. Zobrist doesn't show signs of slowing down next season and I have no problem with his draft position. Along with a speedy team, I really like guys with multiple position eligibility and Zobrist definitely has that.

Closing out the second round with the 24th pick overall, owner Dan Wade of the Twins Most Valuable Blog took 2B Dustin Pedroia. Although Pedroia didn't have an "MVP" season in 2009, you're still getting one of the best 2B in the AL, who can hit for power and average.

With my selection in the third round, I took 3B Michael Young from the Texas Rangers. Young is still very high on my list because of previous seasons. I liked him last year and I really like him heading into next season.

Another great pick in the third round came from owner Paul Sporer (pjs24) of Baseball By Paul when he selected OF/DH Adam Lind. Lind is player who I liked heading into 2009 and when he had a "breakout" season with 35 HR, it sealed the deal. While I'll be curious to see if the RBI totals hit over 100 again, the power and great average are here to stay.

Because many of you love C Matt Wieters, I'll have you know that he was drafted with the 1st pick in the fourth round (third catcher overall).

Some other notable picks of the fourth and fifth rounds which I thought were excellent: OF Shin-Soo Choo, 1B Billy Butler and SS Alexi Ramirez (all in the fourth round) and 3B/2B Gordon Beckham, RHP Jake Peavy and OF B.J. Upton in the fifth round.

Overall, I find my team to be very fast, but lacking power. My outfielders have a mixture of power and speed, but I'm curious to see how OF Jermaine Dye and OF Magglio Ordonez bounce back next season. I'm sure they will get plenty of at-bats, but will they find success? My starting infield is a group of young guys who have the potential to succeed, but I run into the issue of little power. With regards to pitching, I mentioned earlier that I've never been a huge fan of spending high picks on pitching, but that I would rather piece a few low round picks with a few waiver-wire picks. Everyone has their own strategy with regards to pitchers and draft picks, but you have to go with what wins you a championship. My catching situation is just awful...that's really all I can say, but with very little depth, you can't expect to find much value after the top guys are drafted.

I'm a firm believer in practice makes perfect and that's why it's great to get your drafting/ranking work in during the offseason. Heading into drafts next spring with very little practice could cost you later in the season. Not only is it great prep-work for next year, but it's a lot of fun talking baseball with everyone.

Let me know your comments, complaints, opinions and praises. Who do you think had the best draft?

Reggie Yinger is a writer and the co-founder of Baseball Press. He is also a computer programmer. His work has been featured in several print and online publications. He enjoys fantasy baseball and hates when players bunt in baseball.
comments
by Anonymous on Wednesday December 23rd @ 5:05PM
Without looking, I wonder -- does Pedroia really have good power?
by Reggie Yinger on Wednesday December 23rd @ 8:55PM
For a 2B in an AL Only draft, yes...7th overall in the AL for 2B in total HR last season...not known for it...but certainly helps his value..
by Anonymous on Tuesday February 2nd @ 3:37PM
I would have swapped Longoria for Crawford in round 1, then put a big bullseye on Julio Borbon in later rounds. Probably less hr and sb than carl, but far far better value than the 3B likely to be available in the same spot.

Comments are closed.

Copyright © 2009-2013 Baseball Press, LLC | Partner of USA Today Sports Digital Properties | Baseball Press is not affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Major League Baseball Players Association