Log In | Create Account
Reggie Yinger
2010 Fantasy Baseball Rankings - Catcher
Tuesday November 10th, 2009

With the World Series complete, why not turn your focus towards 2010? Baseball Press is kicking off our 2010 Fantasy Positional Rankings with the catching position. Players are eligible for the position if they played at least 10 games at that position in 2009. These are initial rankings heading into draft day and do not reflect the final rankings come October 2010. The statistics listed to each player are his FINAL 2009 numbers, not the projected 2010 stats. Enough jibber-jabber, let's get to it.


RANK Player TEAM POS Stats - 2009
1Joe MauerMINCBATTING - AB 523 AVG .365 OBP .444 R 94 HR 28 RBI 96 SB 4
2Brian McCannATLCBATTING - AB 488 AVG .281 OBP .349 R 63 HR 21 RBI 94 SB 4
3Victor MartinezBOSCBATTING - AB 588 AVG .303 OBP .381 R 88 HR 23 RBI 108 SB 1
41Kurt SuzukiOAKCBATTING - AB 570 AVG .274 OBP .313 R 74 HR 15 RBI 88 SB 8
53Matt WietersBALCBATTING - AB 354 AVG .288 OBP .340 R 35 HR 9 RBI 43 SB 0
6Jorge PosadaNYYCBATTING - AB 383 AVG .285 OBP .363 R 55 HR 22 RBI 81 SB 1
7Mike NapoliLAACBATTING - AB 382 AVG .272 OBP .350 R 60 HR 20 RBI 56 SB 3
82Russell MartinLADCBATTING - AB 505 AVG .250 OBP .352 R 63 HR 7 RBI 53 SB 11
9Ryan DoumitPITCBATTING - AB 280 AVG .250 OBP .299 R 31 HR 10 RBI 38 SB 4
101Geovany SotoCHCCBATTING - AB 331 AVG .218 OBP .321 R 27 HR 11 RBI 47 SB 1
111Chris IannettaCOLCBATTING - AB 289 AVG .228 OBP .344 R 41 HR 16 RBI 52 SB 0
123Yadier MolinaSTLCBATTING - AB 481 AVG .293 OBP .366 R 45 HR 6 RBI 54 SB 9
13Bengie MolinaSFCBATTING - AB 491 AVG .265 OBP .285 R 52 HR 20 RBI 80 SB 0
14A.J. PierzynskiCWSCBATTING - AB 504 AVG .300 OBP .331 R 57 HR 13 RBI 49 SB 1
155Kelly ShoppachTBCBATTING - AB 271 AVG .214 OBP .335 R 33 HR 12 RBI 40 SB 0
16newRamon HernandezCINCBATTING - AB 287 AVG .258 OBP .336 R 25 HR 5 RBI 37 SB 1
1713Miguel MonteroARICBATTING - AB 425 AVG .294 OBP .355 R 61 HR 16 RBI 59 SB 1
18newJeff ClementPITC
19newJohn BuckTORCBATTING - AB 186 AVG .247 OBP .299 R 16 HR 8 RBI 36 SB 1
205Carlos RuizPHICBATTING - AB 322 AVG .255 OBP .355 R 32 HR 9 RBI 43 SB 3
21newNick HundleySDCBATTING - AB 256 AVG .238 OBP .313 R 23 HR 8 RBI 30 SB 5
223John BakerFLACBATTING - AB 373 AVG .271 OBP .349 R 59 HR 9 RBI 50 SB 0
235Jarrod SaltalamacchiaTEXCBATTING - AB 283 AVG .233 OBP .290 R 34 HR 9 RBI 34 SB 0
24newGerald LairdDETCBATTING - AB 413 AVG .225 OBP .306 R 49 HR 4 RBI 33 SB 5
256Jesus FloresWSHCBATTING - AB 93 AVG .301 OBP .371 R 13 HR 4 RBI 15 SB 0
263Dioner NavarroTBCBATTING - AB 376 AVG .218 OBP .261 R 38 HR 8 RBI 32 SB 5
27newAdam MooreSEACBATTING - AB 23 AVG .217 OBP .250 R 4 HR 1 RBI 2 SB 1
28newLou MarsonCLECBATTING - AB 17 AVG .235 OBP .350 R 3 HR 0 RBI 0 SB 0
2912Miguel OlivoCOLCBATTING - AB 390 AVG .249 OBP .292 R 51 HR 23 RBI 65 SB 5
305Alex AvilaDETCBATTING - AB 61 AVG .279 OBP .375 R 9 HR 5 RBI 14 SB 0
318Buster PoseySFCBATTING - AB 17 AVG .118 OBP .118 R 1 HR 0 RBI 0 SB 0
FA* = Free Agent

The first five rankings are pretty standard with the exception of Kurt Suzuki. You could easily flip-flop Suzuki and Miguel Montero, because of Montero's potential to drive in runs from the 4th and 5th spot in the D'backs lineup. If Stephen Drew and Justin Upton can continue to produce, Montero has a real chance of driving in 80-90 runs in 2010.

I think Matt Wieters is ranked appropriately because of his sold finish in 2009. Wieters hit over .300 AVG in his final 65 games with a .765 OPS. The Orioles had Wieters batting third as the season ended in 2009, in which he hit .340 AVG, 2 HR, 7 RBI in 12 games. Some may say I have him ranked too high, but he's proven that he could make the adjustments needed to succeed and that shouldn't change in 2010. All fantasy owners (at least I think) wish for Ryan Doumit would be shipped to a different team (see example Nate McLouth) so that we can see some real production, that's why I ranked him just inside the Top 10. To rank him this high may be a stretch, as he's only played in 100+ games during one of the past five seasons. As of right now, I've given Russell Martin and Geovany Soto rankings just around the Top 10 because even though they had poor 2009 campaigns, they still redeem their starter status and are still viable options heading into 2010.

I hope I'm not the only one who has Chris Iannetta ranked just outside the Top 10, but if I am, I'll gladly take his 20+ HR potential and .270 AVG.

A.J. Pierzynski is another guy like Soto and Martin who I don't expect to hit 20 HR, but they provide a serviceable option for your team in 2010. A.J. should be fine for most of the 2010 season, but he does have Tyler Flowers looming in the background.

Bengie Molina is a 35 year old catcher who provides 20 HR pop and appears to be the everyday starter for the Giants next season.

With the catching market scare this season, Kelly Shoppach becomes a reliable option with the Rays. Shoppach will probably see a bulk of the starts over Dioner Navarro making him a real threat to hit 15 homers.

Jarrod Saltalamacchia and Jesus Flores are my "buy low" picks for 2010. These are two guys who battled injuries in 2009, but still have the talent and are great late round picks. I'm thinking most owners will overlook these guys because of their poor statistical 2009 seasons, but I suspect both will be the number one starter as the season rolls on.

John Baker and John Buck have starting jobs, but that's about it. Neither one will blow you away, but will fill the position if you haven't already grabbed a catcher in your draft.

Jeff Clement is linked to rumors as the Bucs opening day first basemen, but also has catching eligibility this season. Clement has been great in the minors over the past seasons, but has failed to translate that into any kind of success at the big league level. He's ranked for now but that could soon change as spring training will reveal the plan for Clement.

Adam Moore and Lou Marson are nice AL-Only options, but I wouldn't rely on them too heavily in mixed leagues.

Alex Avila is ranked because Gerald Laird was just awful in 2009 and could his playing time cut short in Detroit. The only asset helping Laird is his playing time, but that will change.

Buster Posey's draft day value took a huge hit once the news broke that Molina has re-signed with the Giants.

Reggie Yinger is a writer and the co-founder of Baseball Press. He is also a computer programmer. His work has been featured in several print and online publications. He enjoys fantasy baseball and hates when players bunt in baseball.
comments
by Anonymous on Tuesday November 10th @ 9:19AM
I would drop Doumit outside the top 10.
by Anonymous on Tuesday November 10th @ 2:02PM
Montero too high
by Reggie Yinger on Tuesday November 10th @ 4:11PM
Anonymous #1 - I thought about dropping Doumit outside the Top 10, but he's proven he can produce when healthy.------------------ Anonymous #2 - Like I mentioned, I could flip my 4-7 picks..I think Montero is a good young catcher who has a nice XBH% and AB/HR total.

Comments are closed.

Copyright © 2009-2013 Baseball Press, LLC | Partner of USA Today Sports Digital Properties | Baseball Press is not affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Major League Baseball Players Association